| 1 | Chase McLaughlin | CLE, IND, JAX, LAC, SF, TB | 83.3% | 45/54 |
| 2 | Andre Szmyt | CLE | 83.3% | 5/6 |
| 3 | Giorgio Tavecchio | ATL, LV | 83.3% | 5/6 |
| 4 | Chris Boswell | PIT | 82.5% | 52/63 |
| 5 | Eddy Pineiro | CAR, CHI, NYJ, SF | 81.8% | 18/22 |
| 6 | Cody Parkey | CHI, CLE, MIA, PHI, TEN | 80% | 8/10 |
| 7 | Andy Borregales | NE | 80% | 4/5 |
| 8 | Brandon Aubrey | DAL | 79.5% | 35/44 |
| 9 | Will Reichard | MIN | 79.2% | 19/24 |
| 10 | Cameron Dicker | LAC, PHI | 78.6% | 22/28 |
| 11 | Joshua Karty | LA | 77.8% | 7/9 |
| 12 | Cam Little | JAX | 76.5% | 13/17 |
| 13 | Matt Prater | ARI, ATL, BUF, DEN, DET | 75.2% | 88/117 |
| 14 | Anders Carlson | GB, NYJ, SF | 75% | 6/8 |
| 15 | Garrett Hartley | CLE, NO | 75% | 6/8 |
| 16 | Tyler Bass | BUF | 75% | 21/28 |
| 17 | Stephen Gostkowski | NE, TEN | 73.3% | 33/45 |
| 18 | Ka'imi Fairbairn | HOU | 73% | 54/74 |
| 19 | Robbie Gould | CHI, NYG, SF | 72.7% | 40/55 |
| 20 | Daniel Carlson | LV, MIN | 72.5% | 37/51 |
| 21 | Mike Vanderjagt | DAL, IND | 71.4% | 10/14 |
| 22 | Josh Lambo | JAX, LAC | 70.8% | 17/24 |
| 23 | Blake Grupe | IND, NO | 70.4% | 19/27 |
| 24 | Mike Hollis | BUF, JAX | 70% | 7/10 |
| 25 | Phil Dawson | ARI, CLE, SF | 70% | 42/60 |
| 26 | Jeff Wilkins | LA | 69.7% | 23/33 |
| 27 | Evan McPherson | CIN | 69.6% | 32/46 |
| 28 | Nick Folk | DAL, NE, NYJ, TB, TEN | 69.2% | 54/78 |
| 29 | Graham Gano | CAR, NYG, WAS | 69.1% | 47/68 |
| 30 | Younghoe Koo | ATL, LAC, NYG | 69% | 29/42 |
| 31 | Jason Sanders | MIA | 68.8% | 33/48 |
| 32 | Rob Bironas | TEN | 68.6% | 24/35 |
| 33 | Blair Walsh | MIN, SEA | 68.6% | 24/35 |
| 34 | Jason Myers | JAX, NYJ, SEA | 68.4% | 54/79 |
| 35 | Harrison Butker | KC | 68.3% | 41/60 |
| 36 | David Buehler | DAL | 66.7% | 4/6 |
| 37 | Paul Edinger | CHI, MIN | 66.7% | 16/24 |
| 38 | Chad Ryland | ARI, NE | 66.7% | 12/18 |
| 39 | Dan Bailey | DAL, MIN | 66.7% | 36/54 |
| 40 | Cairo Santos | CHI, KC, LA, TB, TEN | 66.7% | 34/51 |
| 41 | Charlie Smyth | NO | 66.7% | 4/6 |
| 42 | Justin Tucker | BAL | 66.3% | 67/101 |
| 43 | Matt Bryant | ATL, IND, MIA, NYG, TB | 65.6% | 42/64 |
| 44 | Josh Brown | CIN, LA, NYG, SEA | 65.5% | 38/58 |
| 45 | Zane Gonzalez | ARI, ATL, CAR, CLE, WAS | 65.5% | 19/29 |
| 46 | Kai Forbath | DAL, JAX, LA, MIN, NE, NO, WAS | 65% | 13/20 |
| 47 | Jake Moody | CHI, SF, WAS | 64.7% | 11/17 |
| 48 | Martin Gramatica | DAL, IND, NO, TB | 64.3% | 18/28 |
| 49 | Steve Christie | BUF, LAC, NYG | 64.3% | 9/14 |
| 50 | Jason Hanson | DET | 64.1% | 41/64 |
| 51 | Ryan Longwell | GB, MIN | 63.9% | 23/36 |
| 52 | Joey Slye | CAR, HOU, NE, SF, TEN, WAS | 63.6% | 35/55 |
| 53 | Matthew Wright | CAR, HOU, JAX, KC, PIT, SF, TEN | 63.6% | 7/11 |
| 54 | Brett Maher | DAL, LA, NO | 62.9% | 22/35 |
| 55 | Chandler Catanzaro | ARI, CAR, NYJ, TB | 62.5% | 10/16 |
| 56 | Aldrick Rosas | DET, JAX, NO, NYG | 62.5% | 10/16 |
| 57 | Adam Vinatieri | IND, NE | 62.2% | 46/74 |
| 58 | Josh Scobee | JAX, PIT | 61.9% | 26/42 |
| 59 | John Carney | JAX, KC, LAC, NO, NYG | 61.5% | 8/13 |
| 60 | Steven Hauschka | BAL, BUF, DEN, JAX, SEA | 60.9% | 28/46 |
| 61 | Connor Barth | CHI, DEN, KC, TB | 60% | 18/30 |
| 62 | Jake Elliott | PHI | 60% | 33/55 |
| 63 | Jason Elam | ATL, DEN | 59.5% | 22/37 |
| 64 | Jake Bates | DET | 58.8% | 10/17 |
| 65 | Dustin Hopkins | CLE, LAC, WAS | 58.7% | 27/46 |
| 66 | Dan Carpenter | BUF, MIA | 58.5% | 24/41 |
| 67 | Patrick Murray | CLE, TB | 58.3% | 7/12 |
| 68 | Matt Gay | IND, LA, SF, TB, WAS | 58.2% | 32/55 |
| 69 | Joe Nedney | CAR, DEN, LV, SF, TEN | 57.7% | 15/26 |
| 70 | Wil Lutz | DEN, NO | 57.4% | 31/54 |
| 71 | Greg Zuerlein | DAL, LA, NYJ | 57.1% | 52/91 |
| 72 | Brandon McManus | DEN, GB, JAX | 57% | 53/93 |
| 73 | Greg Joseph | CLE, MIN, NYG, NYJ, TEN, WAS | 56.7% | 17/30 |
| 74 | Rian Lindell | BUF, SEA, TB | 56.1% | 23/41 |
| 75 | Jay Feely | ARI, ATL, CHI, MIA, NYG, NYJ | 55.9% | 19/34 |
| 76 | Cade York | CIN, CLE, WAS | 55.6% | 5/9 |
| 77 | Mason Crosby | GB, NYG | 54.8% | 46/84 |
| 78 | Nick Novak | ARI, HOU, KC, LAC, WAS | 54.5% | 18/33 |
| 79 | Shayne Graham | ATL, BAL, BUF, CAR, CIN, HOU, MIA, NE, NO | 54.5% | 18/33 |
| 80 | Sebastian Janikowski | LV, SEA | 54.2% | 58/107 |
| 81 | Riley Patterson | ATL, CLE, DET, JAX, MIA | 53.8% | 7/13 |
| 82 | David Akers | DET, PHI, SF | 53.8% | 28/52 |
| 83 | Kris Brown | HOU, LAC, PIT | 52.9% | 18/34 |
| 84 | Nate Kaeding | LAC, MIA | 52.6% | 10/19 |
| 85 | Lawrence Tynes | KC, NYG | 52.4% | 11/21 |
| 86 | Caleb Sturgis | LAC, MIA, PHI | 52% | 13/25 |
| 87 | Randy Bullock | CIN, HOU, NYG, NYJ, PIT, TEN | 51.7% | 15/29 |
| 88 | Ryan Succop | KC, TB, TEN | 50% | 24/48 |
| 89 | Todd Peterson | ATL, KC, PIT, SEA, SF | 50% | 5/10 |
| 90 | Mike Badgley | BUF, CHI, DET, IND, LAC, TEN | 50% | 9/18 |
| 91 | Matt Stover | BAL, IND | 50% | 9/18 |
| 92 | Neil Rackers | ARI, CIN, HOU | 50% | 26/52 |
| 93 | John Kasay | CAR, NO | 49.1% | 27/55 |
| 94 | Olindo Mare | CAR, CHI, MIA, NO, SEA | 48.7% | 19/39 |
| 95 | Jeff Reed | PIT, SF | 47.1% | 8/17 |
| 96 | Brett Conway | CLE, LV, NYG, NYJ, WAS | 45.5% | 5/11 |
| 97 | Dave Rayner | BUF, CIN, DET, GB, IND, KC | 45.5% | 5/11 |
| 98 | Sam Ficken | LA, NYJ | 44.4% | 4/9 |
| 99 | Mike Nugent | ARI, CHI, CIN, DAL, LV, NE, NYJ, TB | 43.8% | 14/32 |
| 100 | Wade Richey | BAL, LAC, SF | 42.9% | 3/7 |